November 2024, Vol. 251, No. 11
Features
Spotlight on Mexico: Nation’s Biggest Pipeline Projects Still Face Challenges
By Gordon Feller, P&GJ Correspondent
(P&GJ) – Mexico is seeing some pipeline projects move forward, as others stall. But, with a newly elected president taking office, all of them will continue to be subjects of debate, scrutiny and potentially legal challenges.
The progress and impact of these projects will be closely watched, not only within Mexico but also by the international energy community. Each one of the projects represents significant investments in fossil fuel infrastructure at a time of global energy transition.
A significant shift is now underway within the country’s energy landscape – and this is reflected by the development of large-scale oil and gas infrastructure projects in Mexico, particularly the Southeast Gateway Pipeline and the Sierra Madre Gas Pipeline.
These projects have been proposed in ways that advocates say will enhance Mexico’s natural gas transport capacity while supporting power generation and industrial development. However, their implementation faces numerous challenges – and each of these have wider potential consequences.
The Southeast Gateway Pipeline, also known as Gasoducto Puerta al Sureste, is a $4.5 billion project led by TC Energy in partnership with Mexico’s state-owned Federal Electricity Commission (CFE). This 445-mile (715-km) sub-marine gas pipeline will link Tuxpan and Coatzacoalcos ports in Veracruz state with Dos Bocas port in Tabasco state, with a capacity of 1.3 Bcf/d.
For some perspective, CFE is one of Mexico’s largest state-owned national enterprises. It provides transmission services and distribution of electricity. CFE generates and sells electricity, and it imports, exports, transports, stores, purchases and sells natural gas, coal and any other fuel. It develops and executes engineering projects, geological and geophysical activities, research, development and implementation of energy sources.
One of the primary challenges facing the Southeast Gateway Pipeline is the many potential impacts on marine ecosystems. The pipeline’s route passes through sensitive areas, including the Southwestern Gulf of Mexico Reef Corridor. Environmental groups have raised concerns about the threat to coral reefs, particularly in the Veracruz Reef System National Park and the Lobos-Tuxpan Reef System.
TC Energy claims to have invested over $50 million in marine studies and states that the pipeline route does not touch or cross living coral reefs. However, the lack of transparency regarding the project’s environmental impact studies has fueled skepticism among conservationists. Some sections of the environmental impact study, including crucial coordinates, were redacted by officials, raising questions about the thoroughness of the assessment.
The pipeline’s construction sites are near local and Indigenous communities, including the Otomí, Nahua, Totonaco, Nuntajiiyi’ and Tepehua peoples. Many residents argue that they should have been formally consulted about the project, given its potential impact on their livelihoods, which often depend on coastal tourism and fishing. The apparent lack of comprehensive community engagement could lead to social tensions and potential legal challenges as the project progresses.
The construction of the Southeast Gateway Pipeline involves complex technical and logistical operations. The project requires the assembly of massive equipment, such as the four Solar TitanTM130 turbochargers, each weighing over 150 tons. The transportation and installation of this equipment necessitated significant modifications to local infrastructure, including adjustments to access roads.
Furthermore, the project employs innovative technologies like the Direct Pipe Installation system, which combines micro tunnel and HDD technology. While this method offers advantages in terms of safety and versatility, its implementation represents a new challenge for the construction team, as it’s the first time Techint E&C will be using this technology.
The Sierra Madre Gas Pipeline is part of Mexico Pacific’s $15 billion Saguaro Energía LNG project. This 497-mile (800-km) pipeline will run from Guadalupe, Chihuahua to Puerto Libertad, Sonora, with a capacity of 2.8 Bcf/d. While specific details about this project are limited in the provided search results, it’s likely to face similar challenges to the Southeast Gateway Pipeline.
These pipeline projects raise questions about Mexico’s commitment to transitioning away from fossil fuels. While Mexico has pledged to more than double its clean energy output by 2030, the country continues to invest heavily in oil and gas infrastructure. This apparent contradiction could pose challenges in meeting climate change mitigation goals and may face increasing scrutiny from environmental groups and the international community.
Pipeline project proponents argue that these pipelines will enhance Mexico’s energy security and promote economic development, particularly in the country’s southern regions. The Southeast Gateway Pipeline, for instance, is expected to create approximately 4,000 direct and indirect jobs during peak construction. However, the long-term economic benefits must be weighed against the potential environmental costs and the risk of stranded assets as the global energy landscape shifts towards renewables.
The projects have already faced legal challenges. In 2018, an injunction was filed against the Southeast Gateway Gas Pipeline, but it was later struck down after a court ruled the project was a matter of national security. This decision highlights the tension between development priorities and environmental protection. As construction progresses, there’s a possibility of further legal actions, particularly from environmental groups and affected communities.
While modern pipeline technologies offer improved safety features, the risk of accidents or spills remains a concern, especially given the marine environment in which the Southeast Gateway Pipeline will operate. Ensuring the long-term integrity of these pipelines in potentially corrosive saltwater conditions will be crucial.
These pipelines, particularly the Sierra Madre project which will connect with ONEOK’s proposed Saguaro Connector Pipeline at the US-Mexico border, have geopolitical implications. They represent a deepening of energy ties between the United States and Mexico, which could influence broader diplomatic and economic relations between the two countries.
The Southeast Gateway Pipeline and Sierra Madre Gas Pipeline projects represent significant investments in Mexico’s energy infrastructure. While they promise to enhance the country’s natural gas transport capacity and potentially stimulate economic development, they also face a complex array of challenges.
Environmental concerns, particularly regarding marine ecosystems and climate change impacts, are at the forefront of these challenges. The projects’ potential effects on local and Indigenous communities, coupled with questions about the adequacy of consultation processes, could lead to ongoing social and legal conflicts.
Technical and logistical hurdles in construction and operation, especially for the offshore components of the Southeast Gateway Pipeline, will require careful management and innovative solutions. The use of new technologies like the Direct Pipe Installation system presents both opportunities and risks.
Moreover, these projects raise broader questions about Mexico’s energy strategy and its alignment with global trends towards decarbonization. As the world increasingly shifts towards renewable energy sources, the long-term viability and potential for stranded assets must be considered.
Balancing the economic benefits of these pipelines with environmental protection and community rights will be crucial for their successful implementation and operation. Transparent environmental assessments, genuine community engagement, and robust safety measures will be essential in addressing the concerns raised by various stakeholders.
Comments